Maps
Magazine

POLITICS & POLICY MAKING

Opposition Seeks Reduction in Karachi Traffic Fines Amid Criticism of E-Challan System
Sindh Opposition Leader Ali Khorshidi urges reduction of Rs700m in Karachi e-challan fines, while Traffic Minister Zia Lanjar defends system, citing safety and law enforcement.
MH
by Muhammad Hashir
2025-11-28
Opposition Seeks Reduction in Karachi Traffic Fines Amid Criticism of E-Challan System

Opposition Leader in the Sindh Assembly Ali Khorshidi on Friday demanded a reduction in the hefty e-challan fines issued for traffic violations in Karachi, arguing that the current system is overly punitive.

Speaking during a Sindh Assembly session, Khorshidi highlighted that Rs 700 million in fines have been collected from Karachi motorists so far. He questioned why automated traffic cameras have been installed in Karachi but not in other cities. Khorshidi also called for the formation of a parliamentary committee to review traffic challans and accused some traffic personnel of misconduct against citizens.

“Traffic fines in Karachi need to be reduced. Cameras are only installed in Karachi, while other cities remain neglected. Citizens are being harassed,” he said.

Government Response

Law Minister Zia Lanjar defended the issuance of traffic challans, stating that they are necessary for the safety of citizens and the enforcement of laws. He acknowledged that the system in Karachi still requires significant improvement, noting that the city’s traffic system has not yet reached 20 percent of its potential efficiency.

“Laws are not made based on anyone’s caste. These fines are for citizen protection — motorcycles carrying four children, riding without headlights — these are violations we cannot ignore,” the minister said. He added that while the fines may seem high, much of the amount has not been collected and the government has previously waived certain fines.

Zia Lanjar also rejected Khorshidi’s general criticism of traffic wardens, emphasizing that not all personnel behave inappropriately. “We are ready to sit with the opposition and address their concerns,” he added.

He cited examples from Punjab, where similar fines have been implemented, and urged the opposition and public to cooperate in improving Karachi’s traffic system and establishing the writ of law in the city.

Way Forward

The debate underscores ongoing tensions over Karachi’s traffic management, automated enforcement, and citizen grievances. While opposition voices call for fairness and reduction of fines, the government maintains that stringent enforcement is essential for road safety and law compliance.
Tagged:

SindhAssembly

KarachiTraffic

EChallan

AliKhorshidi
Share News: